How to Choose the Best Type of Sunscreen to Use: A Complete Guide

How to Choose the Best Type of Sunscreen to Use: A Complete Guide

Different types of sunscreen with a blue background.

When it comes to protecting our skin from the harmful effects of the sun, choosing the right type of sunscreen is crucial. Different formulations offer varying levels of protection and convenience, each with its pros and cons. This article delves into the nuances of sunscreen types, their safety, health implications, and practical application tips to help you make an informed decision.


Understanding Sunscreen Types

Selecting the appropriate sunscreen can sometimes feel overwhelming given the array of options available. Understanding the fundamental differences between cream-based and spray-on sunscreens can streamline this decision-making process.


Cream-Based vs. Spray-On Sunscreens

Advantages of Cream-Based Sunscreens


Cream-based sunscreens have long been the gold standard for sun protection due to their ease of application and effective coverage. When applied, it's easier to see if you've missed any spots, ensuring comprehensive protection. This visibility is crucial for preventing those sneaky sunburns that can occur if an area is unintentionally left uncovered. Additionally, cream-based sunscreens tend to adhere better to the skin, providing more lasting protection, especially when engaging in water activities or sweating.


From an ingredient standpoint, creams typically incorporate physical blockers like zinc oxide and titanium dioxide, which sit on top of the skin and reflect UV rays. This not only reduces the risk of skin irritation but also minimizes the chances of systemic absorption. These physical blockers are particularly beneficial for people with sensitive skin, providing broad-spectrum protection without the adverse effects associated with some chemical sunscreens.


Limitations of Spray-On Sunscreens

Spray-on sunscreens, while convenient, have several notable drawbacks. One significant issue is that it’s challenging to ensure even and thorough coverage. Users often miss spots or apply too thin a layer, which can result in uneven protection and increased risk of sunburn. Immediately rubbing in spray-on sunscreens after application can help, but it's an extra step that many might overlook.


Moreover, there are concerns regarding the safety of inhaling aerosolized sunscreen chemicals. While the health impacts of inhaling these particles haven't been extensively studied, there are valid apprehensions about potential respiratory issues. Additionally, aerosol sunscreens are flammable, posing a fire hazard especially if used near open flames. These factors combined suggest that while spray-on sunscreens offer convenience, they may not provide the same level of safety and efficacy as their cream-based counterparts.

  • Ensure even application: Spray-on sunscreens must be rubbed in.
  • Be mindful of inhalation risks: Avoid breathing in aerosolized particles.
  • Watch out for flammability: Keep away from open flames.


Safety and Effectiveness of Sunscreen Ingredients

The safety and effectiveness of sunscreen ingredients have been under scrutiny for years, leading to evolving recommendations and guidelines. Understanding the historical context and recent findings can help in making better choices.


Historical Development of Sunscreens

The journey to our current understanding of sunscreens began in the 1800s when it was first discovered that UVB rays caused sunburn. This led to the development of sunscreens specifically designed to block UVB radiation. As time progressed, nearly a century later, the harmful effects of UVA rays were also recognized, prompting the creation of broad-spectrum sunscreens that protect against both UVB and UVA rays.


Interestingly, recent research indicates that infrared and visible light may also contribute to skin damage, including premature aging and an increased risk of cancer. Sunlight, in its entirety, consists of visible light, ultraviolet, and infrared bands. While traditional sunscreens effectively block UV rays, they might not offer adequate protection against infrared and visible light. This revelation underscores the importance of comprehensive sun protection strategies beyond just sunscreen application.


Systemic Absorption of Sunscreen Chemicals

Concerns about the systemic absorption of sunscreen chemicals have been gaining attention, especially following a series of studies by the FDA. These studies revealed that several chemical sunscreen ingredients penetrate the skin more than previously thought, entering the bloodstream at levels that necessitate further safety testing. This discovery is significant because it raises questions about the long-term safety of these chemicals, which have yet to be fully evaluated.


Only two ingredients—zinc oxide and titanium dioxide—have been deemed safe by the FDA. These non-chemical, mineral-based sunscreens do not penetrate the skin and offer a safer alternative. On the other hand, P.A.B.A. and trolamine salicylate have been classified as unsafe and are no longer marketed in the United States. With ongoing scrutiny and research, it remains essential to prioritize mineral sunscreens until more comprehensive safety data is available for the other ingredients.

  • Mineral sunscreens: Safe and effective, preferred options.
  • Chemical sunscreens: Many still under evaluation, avoid uncertain ones.


Sun Exposure and Health Concerns

Sun exposure, while necessary for various bodily functions, also poses significant health risks. Understanding these risks and the role of sunscreen can help mitigate them.


Vitamin D and Sunscreen Use

There's a common misconception that using sunscreen can lead to vitamin D deficiency, given that our bodies synthesize this crucial vitamin upon exposure to UVB rays. However, in practice, this concern doesn't hold much weight. The amount of UVB exposure required to produce adequate vitamin D is quite low, occurring well before any visible changes in skin color, such as tanning or sunburn, happen. This means you can achieve sufficient vitamin D levels without compromising sun protection.


It's also worth noting that many factors influence vitamin D synthesis, including geographic location, skin pigmentation, and lifestyle. Those worried about their vitamin D status can easily supplement through diet or vitamin D supplements, thus ensuring they maintain healthy levels without exposing their skin to harmful UV radiation. This balanced approach allows for effective sun protection while still safeguarding overall health.


Free Radical Damage and Skin Protection

While sunscreens are excellent at blocking UV rays and preventing immediate sun damage like sunburns, they might not fully protect against free radical damage caused by infrared and visible light. Free radicals are unstable molecules that can damage skin cells, leading to premature aging and increased cancer risk. UV radiation has long been known to generate free radicals, but recent research highlights that infrared and visible light also play a role in this damaging process.


This revelation suggests that sunscreen alone may not be sufficient for complete skin protection. Incorporating sun avoidance strategies, such as seeking shade and wearing protective clothing, becomes essential. These methods, combined with the use of broad-spectrum sunscreens, provide a more holistic approach to sun protection, reducing the overall burden of free radical damage on the skin.

  • Holistic protection: Use shade and clothing along with sunscreen.
  • Combat free radicals: Sunscreens alone may not be enough.


Sunscreen Use Across Different Skin Types

Sunscreen recommendations can vary based on skin type and color. Understanding these differences can help ensure everyone gets the protection they need.


Sunscreen Recommendations for Various Skin Colors

Different skin types require different approaches to sun protection. For instance, people with darker skin tones naturally have a higher built-in SPF due to increased melanin, which provides some level of protection against UV radiation. However, this natural SPF, typically around 13 for black skin compared to about 3 for white skin, is not enough to prevent sun damage entirely. Thus, dermatologists recommend using sunscreens with an SPF of 30 or higher for all skin types.


Interventional studies on sunscreen effectiveness specifically for people with dark skin are limited, but the consensus remains that sunscreen is beneficial for everyone. Regardless of skin color, using a broad-spectrum sunscreen can help protect against the cumulative effects of UV radiation, including skin cancer and premature aging. Moreover, newer formulations have addressed cosmetic concerns, making sunscreens more appealing and less noticeable on darker skin tones.


Sunscreen Usage Statistics

Despite the universal need for sun protection, sunscreen usage rates vary significantly across different ethnic groups. Studies show that only about 12 percent of non-Hispanic Blacks and 31 percent of Hispanics regularly use sunscreen, compared to about 44 percent of non-Hispanic whites. This disparity could be attributed to various factors, including cultural differences, misconceptions about the need for sunscreen, and historical marketing practices.


Interestingly, the incidence of melanoma, the deadliest form of skin cancer, is much lower among Hispanics and Blacks compared to whites. However, if melanoma does occur, the mortality rate is higher in these groups, likely due to delayed diagnosis and treatment. This highlights the importance of regular skin checks and prompt medical attention if any unusual skin changes are observed, regardless of ethnic background.

  • Regular skin checks: Vital for early detection and treatment.
  • Encouraging sunscreen use: Targeted education can help bridge the usage gap.


Practical Tips for Sunscreen Application

Ensuring proper application of sunscreen can significantly enhance its effectiveness. Here are some practical tips to get the most out of your sunscreen.


Ensuring Adequate Coverage

To maximize the effectiveness of sunscreen, it's crucial to apply it correctly and thoroughly. For cream-based sunscreens, use a generous amount and spread it evenly across all exposed skin areas. Don't forget often-missed spots like the ears, back of the neck, and tops of the feet. Reapply every two hours or immediately after swimming or sweating to maintain optimal protection.


Spray-on sunscreens require a bit more attention to ensure adequate coverage. Apply a generous amount and then rub it into the skin to ensure even distribution. This step is vital as it reduces the risk of missed spots and provides a uniform protective layer. Additionally, avoid spraying directly onto the face; instead, spray into your hands and then apply to the face to avoid inhalation of potentially harmful chemicals.

  • Generous application: More is better for thorough protection.
  • Frequent reapplication: Every two hours or after swimming/sweating.


Choosing the Right Sunscreen

When selecting a sunscreen, consider opting for mineral-based formulations containing zinc oxide or titanium dioxide. These ingredients are recognized as safe and effective by the FDA and offer broad-spectrum protection without the concerns associated with chemical sunscreens. Additionally, look for products labeled as "micronized" or "nano," as these newer formulations tend to be less noticeable on the skin, addressing the cosmetic concerns that often deter people from regular use.


Mineral sunscreens have come a long way in terms of texture and appearance, making them suitable for all skin types and colors. Whether you have fair, medium, or dark skin, there's a formulation that can provide the necessary protection without leaving a white residue. By choosing the right sunscreen and applying it correctly, you can enjoy the benefits of sun exposure while minimizing the risks to your skin health.

  • Mineral-based formulations: Zinc oxide and titanium dioxide.
  • Micronized products: Less noticeable, more cosmetically appealing.



References: